Supreme Court of Vermont, 1892

Caswell v. Caswell

Caswell v. Caswell
Supreme Court of Vermont · Decided May 15, 1892 · Munson, Rowell, Taet, Taft, Tyler
64 Vt. 557

Caswell v. Caswell

Opinion of the Court

The opinion of the court was delivered by

TAFT, J.

To entitle one to relief in a divorce court, the party must come with clean hands. It is a general doctrine that a man shall not complain of what he knew, or, might have known at the time of the marriage. At the time of the marriage the libellant knew, or had good reason to believe, that the libel-lee would be sentenced to life imprisonment in the State prison under a prior conviction of murder. When one marries a State prison convict it is trifling with the law, for the party to say, she did not know that sentence would follow conviction. A slight delay would have given the knowledge.

The decree is affirmed.

Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.