Downer & Kenney v. Howard
Downer & Kenney v. Howard
Opinion of the Court
It appears from the agreed statement of facts, that Chester Downer and the defendant, Austin Howard, were formerly partners; that Chester Downer deceased February 19, 1890; that commissioners on his estate were appointed and held their first meeting June 25, 1890; that the defendant presented a claim to the commissioners, but no hearing was had before them until July, 1891; that the only matter investigated by the commissioners was the standing of the book accounts between the parties; and that the notes in question were not presented to the commissioners. Chester Downer, at the time of his decease, held three notes against the defendant; and, on the 8th day of October, 1890, the plaintiffs brought this suit declaring on these notes, and secured the same by attachment.
The defendant insists that the plaintiffs are estopped from prosecuting this suit, by reason of their appearing before the commissioners and adjusting the accounts of the parties. When this case was before us on demurrer to the defendant’s pleas, it was held, that, when an executor or administrator commences an action to recover a debt or claim in favor of the estate against a -person having a claim or demand against it, either before or after such person has presented his claim to the commissioners for allowance, and before they have acted thereon, the jurisdiction of the probate court in respect to the claims or demands of either party is ousted by the commencement and pendency of such action;
Judgment reversed pro forma, and cause remanded, with costs to the plaintiffs.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Downer and Kenney, executors v. Austin Howard
- Status
- Published