Niebyski v. Welcome
Niebyski v. Welcome
Opinion of the Court
Tbis is an action of tort, charging tbe defendant with an assault and battery. Plea, tbe general issue. The case comes here on tbe exception of tbe defendant. It has once before been here (Niebyski v. Welcome, 93 Vt. 418, 108 Atl. 341), where tbe facts in tbe ease are fully stated. Tbe plaintiff there claimed, as she here claims, that tbe defendant assaulted her and committed rape upon her person, and that was tbe issue in tbe ease on both trials in tbe county court.
On tbe last trial in tbe county court tbe court was requested to charge tbe jury: ‘ ‘ That if tbe jury should find that tbe plaintiff and defendant bad sexual intercourse upon the occasion in question, tbe plaintiff can recover nothing for that damage, if she consented or voluntarily yielded to such act of intercourse.” At the close of the charge tbe defendant excepted as follows: “We except to the refusal of tbe court to comply with our first request.” Tbe request referred to in tbis exception is the one above quoted.
We think tbe charge given sufficiently covered the matter requested. The substance of the request was, that, if tbe jury found that the plaintiff consented or voluntarily yielded to such act, she could not recover any damage occasioned by such intercourse. Tbe court charged-. “If you find by a preponderance of
This is the only question upon which the review is sought, and, no-error being found in this regard,
Judgment is affirmed.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Anna Niebyski v. Thomas Welcome
- Status
- Published