Lewis v. Simpson
Lewis v. Simpson
Opinion of the Court
'The opinion of the court was delivered by
The appellant brought this action to recover damages for personal injuries received by him while at work in a sawmill alleged to belong to the respondent. At the trial in the superior court the plaintiff was non-suited on the grounds that his evidence showed the injuries he had received were due in part at least to his own negligence, and because his evidence failed to show the defendant's ownership of the mill.
The first ground only will be examined. It appears that appellant had been at work at the mill aforesaid :for some sixteen years. The last year he was engaged in taking away lumber from the pony saw, or “off-bearing,” .as it is sometimes called. Just previous to getting hurt, he had been clearing the track by shoveling away the saw- ■ dust. There was an elevator to remove this sawdust, which .at the time was not running, and the plaintiff went below to adjust the belt thereon, and set the same in motion. To do this it was necessary to get on the opposite side of ;the shaft which operated the belt; for the purpose of placing the belt on the wooden pulley of the elevator, and then
This belt was usually left in position to run the elevator and was only taken off occasionally when repairs were to be made or for some special purpose, and it seemed to be no one’s business in particular to replace it. The plaintiff testified that most anybody put it on. That it would remain on for a week or a month at a time, and sometimes it would have to be adjusted two or three times in a day if something broke. That whenever it was off and he wanted to use the elevator he would go down to fix it, and that he had seen other workmen walk along this beam when they went there. He claimed, however, that placing this belt on was no part of the work that had been assigned to him to do when he was placed at work at the pony saw,
The judgment is affirmed.
Anders, O. J., and Hoyt, Stiles and Dunbar, JJ., concur.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Frank Lewis v. A. M. Simpson
- Cited By
- 6 cases
- Status
- Published
- Syllabus
- MASTER AND SERVANT — INJURY TO EMPLOYE — CONTRIBUTORY NEGLIGENCE. In an action for damages for personal injuries the proof showed that plaintiff had been employed in a sawmill for more than a year, engaged in taking away lumber from the pony saw; that for the purpose of removing sawdust he went below to adjust a belt upon an elevator used for that purpose; that in order to place the belt on the elevator pulley it was necessary to get on the opposite side of the shaft which operated the belt, and then he must return to put it upon the pulley of the shaft; that the shaft was about two feet above the lower floor and plaintiff crawled under it in performing this service, as was his usual practice, and after placing the belt on the elevator pulley, he sought to return by walking on a beam which supported one end of the shaft; that the shaft was revolving rapidly at the time, and there was a set screw at that end projecting about an inch beyond the collar; that the shaft, with collar and screw, was less than a foot high above the beam, and did not extend along the beam more than a foot; that in stepping across the shaft, plaintiff’s overalls caught in the screw and one of his legs was broken. Held, That plaintiff was guilty of contributory negligence, and his action was properly non-suited.