Anderson v. White Co.
Anderson v. White Co.
Opinion of the Court
Respondent brought this action to recover $500, which he alleged as his damages because of the failure of appellant to deliver to him an automobile purchased by him, and upon which he had advanced the sum of $500. The appellant denies any contractual relation with respondent, and contends he purchased the automobile from the Aberdeen Auto Company against whom, if at all, his action should proceed. The court below having found for respondent and awarded him luis judgment as demanded, The White Company appeals.
Some time prior to the date of the transaction complained of, The White Company and the Aberdeen Auto Company entered into a contract whereby the Aberdeen Company was
ABERDEEN AUTO CO.
Representing White’s Steam and Gasoline Cars.
You are hereby authorized to deliver to me, A. J. Anderson, One White Steamer 20 H. P. 00 Automobile, with regular equipment of Shock Absorbers, 2 Gas Head Lamps, 2 Oil Side Lamps, 1 Oil Tail Lamp, Gas Tank (state preference), Horn and Tools, for which I agree to pay Two Thousand Dollars ($2,000) plus the cost of extras and freight charges. I hand you herewith $500, balance payable upon delivery and I desire the following extras, at the prices attached:
Freight charges ..............................$180.00
Top-Side Curtains & Top Cover............... 125.00
Wind Shield ................................. 50.00
Speedometer ................................. 35.00
$390.00
Less discount as per mileage.................. 40.00
Balance...............................$350.00
*570 The above automobile guaranteed three hundred and sixty-five days from date of sale. Tires on the above automobile guaranteed for thirty-five hundred miles.
Color specifications: Body Blue Running Gear standard.
Delivery to be made on or about June 1.
Ship to Aberdeen.
Signature of Purchaser 1
Address of Purchaser L
619 North I j
Salesroom at 218 W. Heron St.
Date April 14, 1910. (Signed) A. J. Anderson.
Signature of Salesman: (Signed) M. M. Stewart.
At the same time, respondent made out a check for $500, payable to Rochford. On the next day the Aberdeen Company sent the following order to The White Company:
STEAM CAR SPECIFICATIONS.
Aberdeen, April 15, 1910.
The White Company,
San Francisco, Cal.
Gentlemen:
In accordance with your Contract Form No. 4 of 1909, please enter our order for the following White Gasoline Cars:
No. Model. “GB” Color. Model 00 Color. Equipment. Month of
Delivery.
1 Touring Blue Top, Glass As soon as Front, Trunk possible Rack
2 Touring Maroon Top, Glass ” Front
'3 Touring Green Top, Glass ” Front
Date of order April 15th, 1910. Ordered by
(Signed) . Aberdeen Auto Co.
M. M. Stewart.
It is conceded that the first car named in this order was the one ordered by respondent. When this order was sent, the $500 check given to Rochford by respondent was cashed, a draft for $500 purchased and mailed with the order as a deposit on the three cars, and on receipt the same was cred
The contract entered into by respondent seems to us conclusive of the appellant’s contention that the contract of purchase of this machine was made with the Aberdeen Company, and that its only connection with the matter was in the filling of the order sent it by the Aberdeen Company. To hold otherwise, is to entirely disregard all the documentary evidence in the case. Respondent places much reliance upon the memorandum, an unsigned copy of which
The judgment is therefore reversed.
Dunbar, C. J., Ellis, and Mount, JJ., concur.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.