State ex rel. United Auto Transportation Co. v. Department of Public Works
Cases that cite this one
14 later published cases cite this decision.
- State Ex Rel. Puget Sound Navigation Co. v. Department of Public Works (Wash. 1931)
- Pacific Northwest Transportation Services, Inc. v. Utilities & Transportation Commission (Wash. Ct. App. 1998)
- Northwest Greyhound Lines, Inc. v. Department of Transportation (Wash. 1949)
- Robinson v. Gallagher Transfer & Storage Co. (Wyo. 1942)
- Arizona Corp. Commission v. Hopkins (Ariz. 1938)
- Furstenberg v. Omaha & Council Bluffs Street Railway Co. (Neb. 1937)
- S & S Auto Freight v. Department of Public Works (Wash. 1933)
- Kitsap County Transportation Co. v. Department of Public Works (Wash. 1932)
- Denman v. Department of Public Works (Wash. 1930)
- North Coast Transportation Co. v. Department of Public Works (Wash. 1930)
- North Bend Stage Line, Inc. v. Denney (Wash. 1929)
- Pacific Northwest Traction Co. v. Department of Public Works (Wash. 1929)
- Deppman v. Department of Public Works (Wash. 1929)
- Interstate Motor Transit Co. v. Kuykendall (District Court, W.D. Washington 1922)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
— The respondents having granted to George Miller a certificate of necessity and convenience for the conducting of an auto transportation service between Miller Station and Camp Lewis, the relator brought the matter before the superior court, and from a judgment there affirming the order of respondents, has appealed.
The testimony shows that the relator was operating an auto transportation line between Tacoma and Camp Lewis on January 15, 1921, and that by virtue of that fact was entitled to and was granted a certificate covering that route and intermediate points, under ch. Ill,
It is the relator’s contention that, under § 4 of ch. Ill, p. 341, Laws of 1921, the respondents could not grant a certificate to Miller in the absence of an order, after a proper hearing before the department, directing the relator to provide satisfactory service, and after a refusal of the relator to obey the order of the respondents to provide additional service, or to change the fares charged passengers. In this case the certificate was issued to Miller without, according to the relator, such a hearing, and without the making of any such order. So far as material, § 4 is as follows:
“. . . . The Commission shall have power, after hearing, when the applicant requests a certificate to operate in a territory already served by a certificate holder under this act, only when the existing auto transportation company or companies, serving such territory will not provide the same to the satisfaction of the Commission, . . .” [Rem. Comp. Stat., § 6390.]
As we read it, the contention of the relator must be sustained, if, as a matter of fact, Miller Station is “territory already served by a certificate holder.”
This question of fact must also be resolved in favor of the relator. As we have noted, the relator main
The questions of whether the service is adequate, or whether the rates charged by relator are proper, are questions which, under the law, the relator is entitled to a hearing upon, and it is only after a hearing and an order entered directing the relator to change its schedule or rates, and a .refusal by the relator to obey that order, that respondents have power to issue a certificate to some other person to then inaugurate a new service.
For these reasons, the judgment of the superior court sustaining the granting of the order of necessity to George Miller by the respondents is reversed and the commission’s order is set aside.
Parker, C. J., Main, Holcomb, and Hovey, JJ., concur.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.