Hayes v. Automobile Insurance Exchange
Cases that cite this one
14 later published cases cite this decision.
- McCann v. Reeder (Wash. 1934)
- Hein v. Family Life Insurance (Wash. 1962)
- Perry v. Continental Insurance Co. (Wash. 1934)
- Kay v. Occidental Life Insurance (Wash. 1947)
- Fidelity & Guaranty Fire Corp. v. Bilquist (9th Cir. 1940)
- Schoeffel v. United States (Court of Claims 1971)
- Robert D. Maland and Bonnie J. Maland v. Houston Fire and Casualty Insurance Company of Fort Worth, Texas, a Corporation, and Patricia Royston (9th Cir. 1960)
- Redden v. Constitution Life Insurance (Ohio Ct. App. 1960)
- Carew, Shaw & Bernasconi, Inc. v. General Casualty Co. of America (Wash. 1937)
- Johnson v. Shell Oil Co. of California (Wash. 1936)
- Mutual Life Insurance Co. of New York v. Campbell (Wash. 1932)
- Williams v. Pacific States Fire Ins. Co. (Or. 1926)
- Hayes v. Automobile Insurance Exchange (Wash. 1924)
- Busboom v. Capital Fire Insurance (Neb. 1924)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
— This is an action on a policy of insurance issued to the respondent by the appellant to cover an automobile, subsequently damaged by fire. The appellant defended on the ground that warranties made by the respondent had been breached and that it was therefore not liable. The contention of the respondent is that he is not responsible for the making of the warranties. Assuming the respondent’s version of the facts, they are that he sought the insurance by
Whether he read it or not is immaterial. It was his duty to read it, and the law says that he did read it. It showed statements which he knew were untrue and without which he could not have obtained the insurance. It becomes immaterial whether or not originally in the application the blanks were filled in by the appellant’s agent without the respondent’s knowledge; in effect, they were the respondent’s own statements when he received the policy containing the instruction “Read your policy” and retained it. Those cases holding the company responsible for false statements written by its agent without the assured’s knowledge do not go to the extent of relieving the assured when he has' not'acted in good faith, and good faith is negatived here by the respondent’s failure to call attention to the falsities when they appeared in the body of the policy itself.
. Nor does the case fall within that other rule that' the assured is not responsible where the company’s agent has advised him that the statements are proper ones
If the assured is not chargeable with the falsity of the statements if not made with intent to deceive (§7078, Rem. Comp. Stat.) [P. C. §2941], still, here the statements were made with knowledge of their untruth, and the burden is on the assured to establish innocent intent. This he cannot do by simply remaining silent. Quinn v. Mutual Life Ins. Co., 91 Wash. 543, 158 Pac. 82; Day v. St. Paul Fire & Marine Ins. Co., 111 Wash. 49, 189 Pac. 95; Devenny v. Automobile Owners Inter-Insurance Association, 124 Wash. 453, 214 Pac. 833.
The respondent should have been nonsuited. Judgment reversed.
Main-, C. J., Bbidges, Holcomb, and Mitchell, JJ., concur.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.