Douglass v. State
Cases that cite this one
20 later published cases cite this decision.
- State v. Walton (Or. 1907)
- Browning v. State (Neb. 1898)
- State v. Trabbold (Superior Court of Delaware 1952)
- State v. Burwell (Idaho 1947)
- State v. Suick (Wis. 1928)
- State v. Poynter (Idaho 1921)
- State v. Prouty (Vt. 1920)
- People v. Weeks (Mich. 1911)
- State v. Beatty (W. Va. 1902)
- Shelp v. United States (9th Cir. 1897)
- State v. Fiester (Or. 1897)
- State v. Bronkol (N.D. 1896)
- Gaines v. United States (Court Of Appeals Of Indian Territory 1895)
- Territory of Arizona v. Blevins (Ariz. 1893)
- Ray v. People (Colo. 1882)
- Weaver v. State (Ind. 1882)
- People v. Gaines (Cal. 1877)
- Davis v. State (Wis. 1875)
- United States v. Conklin (U.S. Circuit Court for the District of Southern Ohio 1873)
- Dixon v. State (Fla. 1869)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
By the Court,
It appears from tire record in this case, that, at the October term, AID. 1853, of the Jefferson Circuit Court, the defendant below was indicted for erecting and maintaining a nuisance ; that the said defendant was arrested the 19th day of April, A. D. 1854, and recognised for his appearance to answer said indictment at the April term of said court, 1854. That at the April term aforesaid, the District Attorney brought on the trial, the defendant being “personally present, and by his counsel consenting to go to trial.” But it does not appear that he was ever arraigned; that the indictment was ever read to him; that he was called upon to plead, or that he did plead to the indictment. A jury was
The record in this case, fails to show any issue which the jury was called upon to try. It is the business and duty of the prosecuting officer of the government, to move on the trial of criminal cases, and to see that the proper issue be made up. It may be probable that the defendant in this case was perfectly aware of the oftence with which he was charged. It appears that he consented to go to trial. But a trial of what did he consent to ? He was arrested and held in custody under the process of the court. It was his right to be informed, and it was the duty of the government to inform him of the accusation against him. This is done by arraignment, and requiring the defendant to plead. It is true, this right of arraignment may, in minor offences, be waived, but a plea, an issue, is absolutely essential. Nor can we supply an issue corresponding to the verdict, when the record is entirely silent on the subject. This record does not disclose any matter from which we can intend the proper issue. Indeed, the bill of exceptions shows positively, that there was none, either in form or substance. It was probably amere inadvertence, but it is fatal to the proceedings. It would be a dangerous precedent to hold that the court could here supply an issue after verdict, or that the defend
The judgment of the Circuit Court is reversed, and cause remanded for further proceedings.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.