Stacy v. Dane County Bank
Cases that cite this one
12 later published cases cite this decision.
- Taylor & Bournique Co. v. National Bank of Ashtabula (District Court, N.D. Ohio 1919)
- Schloss Bros. & Co. v. Gibson Dry Goods Co. (Ala. Ct. App. 1912)
- First National Bank v. German Bank (Iowa 1899)
- Irwin v. Reeves Pulley Co. (Ind. Ct. App. 1897)
- Plymouth County Bank v. Gilman (S.D. 1896)
- Waterloo Milling Co. v. H. Kuenster & Co. (Ill. 1895)
- First National Bank v. Sprague (Neb. 1892)
- Blakeslee v. Hewett (Wis. 1890)
- Simpson v. Waldby (Mich. 1886)
- Exchange Nat. Bank of Pittsburgh v. Third Nat. Bank of NY (Supreme Court of the United States 1884)
- Bank of Lindsborg v. Ober & Hageman (Kan. 1884)
- Guelich v. National State Bank (Iowa 1881)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
By the Court,
The respondent received from the appellants, for collection, a note against parties residing in Stoughton, about twenty miles distant from Madison, where the bank is located. It was placed by the bank, in due time, in the hands of the American Express Company, a part of whose business was to collect commercial paper, and was taken by it to Stoughton, and delivered to a notary public, who presented and protested it on the second day of grace, whereby the indorser was discharged, and the debt lost. This suit is now brought against the bank to recover its amount.
The theory of the plaintiffs is, that the bank, having received the note for collection, was bound to make due presentment, and give due notice to the indorser, and that it was responsible for the negligence or incapacity of any sub-agents whom it employed for this purpose. The bank, on
A different rule has prevailed in New York; though it was there first decided by the supreme court in accordance with tbe rule as above stated. 15 Wend., 482. That decision was, however, overruled by tbe court of errors, 22 Wend., 215, which has been subsequently followed in that state. It is placed, however, expressly on the ground of the authority of that case, which is impliedly admitted to be in conflict with the commercial rule, as settled in other states. See Montgomery County Bank vs. Albany City Bank, 3 Seld., 463. And the reasoning of the New York courts has not induced the courts of other states to change their decisions. Sec case cited from 1 Cushing.
The testimony in the case showed that there was no bank at Stoughton; that the express company did business and had an office there; and that it was responsible, and was a prompt and reliable collecting agent. We think, upon these facts, the bank discharged its duty by placing the note in the hands of the express company.
The authorities cited also sustain the position that it would
These conclusions dispose of the exceptions taken.
The judgment is affirmed, with costs.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.