Smith v. Swarthout
Cases that cite this one
1 later published case cites this decision.
- Estate of Johnson (Wis. 1920)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
By the Court,
Tbe appellant contends that under 'the circumstances of this case be bad a right to be sworn in his own behalf on the trial, though he bad given no notice -of his intended examination as required by the statute. This claim is founded on tbe following facts. After issue was joined in tbe cause, tbe attorney of tbe respondent made
It can hardly be necessary to remark that the statute which enables parties, under certain circumstances, to become witnesses in their own behalf, is an innovation upon the common law rule, which excluded them on the ground of interest. The legislature has seen proper to change this rule, and to provide when a party may be examined on his own behalf on the trial. The fact that the person is a party to the action and interested in the event of the suit, is no longer a ground for exclusion, unless the case comes within the exceptions mentioned in the statute. But still a party is not placed upon the same ground as disinterested witnesses. His right to become a witness is not unlimited. It must be exercised upon the condition and under the circumstances imposed by the statute. And the condition is, that “notice of the intended examination of a party in his own behalf shall be given the opposite party for such time as the court shall deem reasonable in 'order to enable such opposite party to be present at the trial or have his deposition taken.” This is the language of the statute. In Hubbell vs. Noonan, 8 Wis., 214, this court had occasion to consider what was
If the appellant had desired to testify in his own behalf, he should have given proper notice of his intended examination. This is a condition required by the statute, and it is easily complied with. And as this notice was not given, we
The question put to tbe witness Watson, and ruled out, was clearly improper. He was asked if be bad seen tbe mare — for which the note sued on, was given — balk, in the beginning of the winter of 1857. The answer states that the mare was bought on the 12th of October previous, and was then warranted to be sound, kind, gentle and fitted to be used single or in a team with another horse. Now it is obvious the mare might have been all she was warranted and represented to be in October, but still, by bad driving and usage, might have been rendered balky before winter. The question, therefore, related to a period too remote to prove a breach of tbe warranty set up in tbe answer as a defense to the note.
The judgment of the circuit court is therefore affirmed, with costs.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.