Ingles v. Merriman
Ingles v. Merriman
Opinion of the Court
Ro exceptions to the findings of fact or conclusions of law were preserved in the bill of exceptions; hence the only question before us is whether the pleadings and findings sustain the judgment. Wille v. Bartz, 88 Wis. 424.
This seems a very appropriate case for the exercise of the remedial powers of a court of equity. In effect, it is an action for the reformation of deeds. The plaintiff purchased her land in August, 1894. Both she and her grantors purchased and took possession of a certain tract of land, ten rods by sixteen rods, on the north end of the block, which they supposed was correctly described in their deeds. In fact, it was correctly described according to the unrecorded plat which was used in making the various conveyances, but incorrectly described according to the recorded plat which must govern. The same state of facts existed with reference to the deeds and the purchase and possession of the grantors of the defendant. They bought and occupied the balance of the block on the south under a description correct according to the unrecorded plat, and incorrect according to the recorded plat. The defendant purchased knowing
The tax deed covering the south half of lot 4, which the defendant bought in 1894, just before she purchased the south half of lots 4 and 7, plainly does not help her, because she then knew of the errors in the numbering of the lots, both in the conveyances and in the tax proceedings, and under these circumstances her purchase of the certificates would amount simply to payment of her own taxes.
Upon the1 defendant’s appeal the judgment must be affirmed.
The plaintiff appeals because costs were not allowed her. The allowance of costs was within the discretion of the trial court. This discretion is a legal discretion. R. S. sec. 2918. Costs are not to be refused to the prevailing party in the absence of special circumstances reasonably sufficient to require a departure from the ordinary rule. Spengler v. Hahn, 95 Wis. 472. We suppose costs were refused here because the plaintiff did not tender her deed before action com
By the Oouri.— Judgment affirmed on both appeals.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- Ingles v. Merriman, Appellant Ingles v. Merriman
- Status
- Published