Olson v. White Star Lumber Co.
Olson v. White Star Lumber Co.
Opinion of the Court
The plaintiff claims that he sold and delivered to the defendant a certain amount of birch, hemlock, basswood, and maple logs and that they were scaled by one William Olson and one Liscau; that the amount's due therefor according to such scales were respectively $890.09 and $837.12. The defendant claims that the total amount due for the logs was $680.53 and that all but $4.20 had been paid, and tendered judgment for this balance. The issue thus presented by the pleadings raised the material issue litigated at
The court denied defendant’s motion to set aside the verdict and for a new trial and awarded judgment for the plaintiff in the sum of $166.64.
It is contended that the court erred in its instructions to the jury by directing them that upon the issues raised in the action the evidence presented but the one inquiry, namely, whether the plaintiff’s or the defendant’s scale of the logs was correct, and if they found that the- plaintiff was entitled to recover, then they must award him the sum of $166.64, the amount he claimed. It is plain from the record that the only controverted question between the parties involved the inquiry of the actual quantity of logs the plaintiff had sold and delivered to the defendant. Thé court properly submitted this to the jury under appropriate instructions. Under the evidence the court also properly informed the jury of the correct amount due plaintiff, if they found that the plaintiff’s scale was accurate and true.
The defendant urges an exception to the admission in evidence of a tabulated statement of the quantity of the different kinds of logs delivered by plaintiff and the amount due
By the Court. — The judgment appealed from is affirmed.
Case-law data current through December 31, 2025. Source: CourtListener bulk data.