Vilter v. Leenhouts
Vilter v. Leenhouts
Opinion of the Court
This is a novel proceeding. That is all that can be said by way of encomium. It is without authority in precedent. It finds no support in reason. Considerations of expediency or exigency cannot be urged in its behalf.
By its order to show cause the circuit court for Waukesha county seeks to draw into the proceedings for the incorporation of the village of Chenequa an independent controversy entirely foreign to the incorporation proceedings. The declared intention of the assessor of incomes of Milwaukee county to assess an income tax upon the petitioners in.no manner threatened the integrity of the order of incorporation. It constituted no menace to the continued existence of the village of Chenequa as a corporate entity. It was simply a controversy between the income tax assessor of Milwaukee county and certain residents of the village of Chenequa. It was of no more interest to the village of Chenequa than a similar controversy between the income tax assessor of Milwaukee county and a resident of Kenosha would be to the
In the face of the proposed action of the income tax assessor of Milwaukee county, petitioners had available the same remedies that they might have invoked had they been residents of Waukesha or Sheboygan. If it be true, as claimed by them, that the finding of the circuit court for Waukesha county in the incorporation proceedings that they were residents of Chenequa be conclusive and binding upon all the world as to their residence, that finding will be available to them as evidence in an appropriate proceeding to test the authority of the income tax assessor of Milwaukee county to assess an'income tax against them. The conclusive effect of judgments is not maintained by injunction issued by the court rendering the judgment. Where a judgment is claimed to be res adjudicata, it is offered in evidence in the case or proceeding in which its conclusive effect is sought to be established.
By the Court. — The order appealed from is reversed, and the cause remanded with instructions to dismiss the petition.
Reference
- Full Case Name
- In re Incorporation of Village of Chenequa: Vilter and others v. Leenhouts, Assessor of Incomes
- Status
- Published