Whalen v. Finn
Cases that cite this one
1 later published case cites this decision.
- Banking Commission v. Ray (Wis. 1934)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
The following opinion was filed January 12, 1932:
At the time the levy was made the title to the property and the possession of it was in the owner of
“(2) The mortgagor, his wife, his assignee or assignees, may at any time after sale, within five days, redeem the property sold at the chattel mortgage sale at the actual amount at which the same was sold, plus any expense necessary for the keeping of said property subsequent to the sale, and said property shall not be removed from the town in which said sale took place before the right of redemption expires. Any person aggrieved by a violation of any provision of this section may recover of the person who violated the same, in addition to his actual damages, twenty-five dollars as liquidated damages. If any such property is sold at private sale, without public notice, or is sold within the period herein limited, without such consent the mortgage debt shall be deemed paid and the mortgage securing the same be deemed canceled.”
The contention of the respondent that this statute merely extends the period of redemption for five days beyond the sale, and that this right to redeem is an interest owned by the mortgagor and is therefore subject to levy and sale under execution, suggests the question for consideration.
The right of redemption as generally understood, if exercised, carries with it the obligation to pay the full amount of the mortgage indebtedness. The worth of an equity of redemption is arrived at by subtracting the amount of incumbrance from the value of the property. The property in which the mortgagor has the equity of redemption is subject to the usual remedies available to a creditor, but he must deal with the whole interest of the debtor including the obligation and the incumbrance.
This right must be immune from the execution, for the plain purpose of the statute is to enable a mortgagor, his wife, or some friend, to protect the mortgagor against a sale at an unusually low price. The mortgagee, in the absence of contending bids at the foreclosure sale, secures the property at a very low figure. He has foreclosed his
The mortgagee sets a price which under the statute the mortgagor may pay and take his property back. If the mortgagor redeems the property and it is not otherwise exempt, his creditors would have the usual rights. The mortgagor is thus enabled to protect himself against the disadvantages of a foreclosure sale. This privilege is framed and designed to prevent the unfortunate citizen from losing his property without receiving a fair allowance for it. The spirit back of such legislation is wholesome. It is tq help the unfortunate or improvident debtor away from a complete loss and to encourage reconstruction of his affairs so as to enable him in some measure to protect those immediately dependent upon him by saving his property or getting full value therefor, and under this scheme the mortgagee does not suffer because he fixes the price on the goods taken under the foreclosure sale. When he is paid the price which he fixed he must be satisfied and for collection of his deficiency avail himself of the means that all creditors have.
At the time the levy was made the title to the property was in the Bank of Oregon and the levy did not affect the right of the mortgagor to redeem. There having been no levy since redemption which would affect the rights of the plaintiffs, a cause of action is stated and the demurrer should have been overruled.
By the Court. — Order reversed, and cause remanded for further proceedings according to law.
A motion for a rehearing was denied, with $25 costs, on March 8, 1932.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.