IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF WEST VIRGINIA CHARLESTON DIVISION IN RE: BOSTON SCIENTIFIC CORP. PELVIC REPAIR SYSTEM PRODUCTS LIABILITY LITIGATION MDL No. 2326 THIS DOCUMENT RELATES TO THE CASES LISTED ON EXHIBITA MEMORANDUM OPINION AND ORDER Pending in the cases listed on Exhibit A attached hereto are motions to dismiss Boston Scientific Corp. (“BSC”) with prejudice for plaintiffs’ failure to serve Plaintiff Fact Sheets pursuant to deadlines and requirements established by the court’s previous pretrial order. No plaintiff on Exhibit A has responded to BSC’s motion filed in each individual case. The court finds, pursuant to Rules 16 and 37 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure and after weighing the factors identified in Wilson v. Volkswagen of Am., Inc.,

(4th Cir. 1977), the cases on Exhibit A should be dismissed without prejudice for failure to serve Plaintiff Fact Sheets in compliance with the court’s previous pretrial order. Therefore, the court ORDERS that the motions to dismiss pending in the cases on Exhibit A are GRANTED in part to the extent BSC seeks dismissal and DENIED insofar as BSC seeks dismissal with prejudice. The court ORDERS that the cases on Exhibit A are dismissed without prejudice and stricken from the court’s docket. The court DIRECTS the Clerk to send a copy of this Order to counsel of record and any unrepresented party. ENTER: January 11, 2019 , 277

ALVAREZ, Marlene and Rodolfo Alvarez vs. Boston 1 2:14-cv-04772 Scientific Corporation ARMENDARIZ, Carmen and Jesus Armendariz vs. 2 2: 13-cv-18445 Boston Scientific Corporation ASHMORE, Donna vs. Boston Scientific 3 2:14-cv-27614 Corporation 4 2:15-cv-11492 BALLWEG, Karen vs. Boston Scientific Corporation BAYBROOK, Stephanie and Robert Baybrook vs. 5 2:14-cv-11862 Boston Scientific Corporation BERG, Theresa and Bruce Berg vs. Boston Scientific 6 2:16-cv-03136 Corporation 7 2:15-cv-02116 BORDER, Karen vs. Boston Scientific Corporation 8 2:18-cv-00359 Brickner v. Boston Scientific Corporation 9 2:18-cv-01080 Brooks v. Boston Scientific Corporation BROWN-EASTER, Regina vs. Boston Scientific 10 2:14-cv-21311 Corporation BRUMMETT, Karen G. vs. Boston Scientific 11 2:17-cv-03019 Corporation BUCELLI, Megan Beth vs. Boston Scientific 12 2:13-cv-24478 Corporation 13 2:12-cv-01397 BUCK, Janette vs. Boston Scientific Corporation CALDWELL, Rochelle and Dwayne Caldwell vs. 14 2:14-cv-27515 Boston Scientific Corporation COLLINS, Janise L. vs. Boston Scientific 15 2:12-cv-04881 Corporation COLLINS, Deborah vs. Boston Scientific 16 2:15-cv-06225 Corporation, CURTNER, Cynthia and John Curtner vs. Boston 17 2:13-cv-18296 Scientific Corporation 18 2:12-cv-00770 DAVIS, Tina vs. Boston Scientific Corporation DUBOIS-JEAN, Margarette vs. Boston Scientific 19 2:14-cv-04455 Corporation ENRIQUEZ, Dorothy vs. Boston Scientific 20 2:14-cv-15794 Corporation FUSS, Justine and George Fuss vs. Boston Scientific 21 2:13-cv-22978 Corporation GARCIA, Roberta and Raynaldo Garcia vs. Boston 22 2:13-cv-21783 Scientific Corporation 23 2:15-cv-10555 GIESER, Karen vs. Boston Scientific Corporation 24 2:13-cv-31332 GINN, Marylou vs. Boston Scientific Corporation 25 2:13-cv-16249 GOFORTH, Wilda vs. Boston Scientific Corporation GREATHOUSE, Jenis vs. Boston Scientific 26 2:14-cv-06253 Corporation GRUBBS, Margarita and Jimmy Kenneth Grubbs vs. 27 2:16-cv-05576 Boston Scientific Corporation HALL, Carol and Steve Hall vs. Boston Scientific 28 2:16-cv-03050 Corporation HAMMONDS, Richelle L. vs. Boston Scientific 29 2:13-cv-01731 Corporation 30 2:13-cv-28138 HARTNESS, Amy vs. Boston Scientific Corporation HERBERT, Christine vs. Boston Scientific 31 2:15-cv-13092 Corporation HYLAND, Kimberly vs. Boston Scientific 32 2:14-cv-20861 Corporation 33 2:18-cv-01205 Jacomet et al v. Boston Scientific Corporation 34 2:14-cv-00043 JIMENEZ, Kelli vs. Boston Scientific Corporation 35 2:13-cv-27794 Johnson et al v. Boston Scientific Corporation WRIGHT, Veronica and Mark Lespinasse vs. Boston 36 2:14-cv-11987 Scientific Corporation YOCUM, Karen Topham and Richard Yocum vs. 37 2:14-cv-08046 Boston Scientific Corporation KILGORE, Margie and Donald Kilgore vs. Boston 38 2:13-cv-17132 Scientific Corporation 39 2:13-cv-24491 KNIGHT, Pennie vs. Boston Scientific Corporation 40 2:18-cv-00334 Lappe et al v. Boston Scientific Corporation LARIMORE, Angela vs. Boston Scientific 41 2:15-cv-07256 Corporation 42 2:13-cv-16773 LARVIE, Lynda vs. Boston Scientific Corp. 43 2:18-cv-00556 Lloyd et al v. Boston Scientific Corporation LUCERO, Rose and Robert Lucero vs. Boston 44 2:13-cv-04994 Scientific Corporation MACMILLAN, Ruth vs. Boston Scientific 45 2:14-cv-21616 Corporation 46 2:13-cv-02846 MADDOX, Shirley vs. Boston Scientific Corporation MARTIN, Teia Dion and Brad Neal Martin vs. 47 2:12-cv-08209 Boston Scientific Corporation 48 2:12-cv-09004 MARTIN, Lucinda vs. Boston Scientific Corporation MULLARKEY, Debra vs. Boston Scientific 49 2:14-cv-04321 Corporation 50 2:14-cv-04114 MURRAH, Judy vs. Boston Scientific Corporation NOTO, MaryAlice and Anthony Noto vs. Boston NUNEZ, Velma Vaesa and Lorenzo Nunez vs. 52 2:16-cv-05563 Boston Scientific Corporation PAGE, Maureen Margaret and Daivd Page vs. Boston 53 2:14-cv-13065 Scientific Corporation 54 2:13-cv-23052 PARKER, Anita Jo vs. Boston Scientific Corporation 55 2:14-cv-14068 PETERS, Elizabeth vs. Boston Scientific Corporation PLUMMER, Jerri and Michael Plummer vs. Boston 56 2:16-cv-07652 Scientific Corporation PROCTOR, Elaine and George Sinclair vs. Boston 57 2:15-cv-00904 Scientific Corporation 58 2:14-cv-06266 PRUITT, Alexis vs. Boston Scientific Corporation 59 2:14-cv-25446 REED, Irene vs. Boston Scientific Corporation RICE, Betty and Steven L. Rice vs. Boston Scientific 60 2:16-cv-03620 Corporation RIOS, Terry and Wayne Budgell vs. Boston 61 2:13-cv-23031 Scientific Corporation ROBERTS, Joanna and Edward Roberts vs. Boston Scientific, Inc. and John Doe Corporations 1-50 62 2:12-cv-03188 (fictitious) 63 2:18-cv-00719 Rock v. Boston Scientific Corporation RODRIGUEZ, Andrea and Arturo Cortez vs. Boston 64 2:13-cv-18311 Scientific Corporation RODRIGUEZ, Olivia A. vs. Boston Scientific 65 2:14-cv-30521 Corporation 66 2:13-cv-27789 ROGERS, Kamelia vs. Boston Scientific Corporation 67 2:18-cv-00297 Rogers v. Boston Scientific Corporation et al 68 2:18-cv-01102 Rubio et al v. Boston Scientific Corporation 69 2:18-cv-00578 Sanders v. Boston Scientific Corporation et al SCHEIBNER, Sharron K. vs. Boston Scientific 70 2:14-cv-30103 Corporation 71 2:18-cv-01168 Selig v. Boston Scientific Corporation SHEARER, Heather A. vs. Boston Scientific 72 2:14-cv-21181 Corporation SHIELDS, Joan Carol vs. Boston Scientific 73 2:14-cv-07062 Corporation SMITH, Sandra and John Smith vs. Boston Scientific, 74 2:12-cv-03317 Inc. and John Doe Corporations 1-50 (fictitious) 75 2:16-cv-03070 THOMAS, Carolyn vs. Boston Scientific Corporation TOELLNER, Norma vs. Boston Scientific 76 2:16-cv-01957 Corporation 77 2:13-cv-11695 TOON, Regina vs. Boston Scientific Corporation 78 2:13-cv-12261 TURNER, Daphne vs. Boston Scientific Corporation WESTBY, Dorothy and Jerry L. Farquhar vs. Boston 79 2:13-cv-00503 Scientific Corporation WHATLEY, Jessica and Joshua Whatley vs. Boston 80 2:14-cv-06297 Scientific Corporation