Crim v. Holsberry
Cases that cite this one
3 later published cases cite this decision.
- West v. Belches (Va. 1816)
- West v. Belches (Va. 1816)
- Grant v. Swank (W. Va. 1914)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
In the chancery case of J. N. B. Crim against U. F. Holsberry et al., J. A. Bishop, a judgment creditor, defendant, appeals from a final decree confirming the commissioner’s report executing an order of reference, ascertaining and fixing the liens and their priorities, and directing a sale of the lands of defendant U. F. Holsberry. Numerous errors are assigned. No exception was taken to the commissioner’s report for want of proper notice or the allowance of taxes as a lien on the land. Therefore, as to these matters, the report must be taken as conclusive, as they might be affected by extraneous testimony. Kester v. Lyon, 40 W. Va. 161 (20 S. E. 933). No objection was made to the filing of the answers of William and Bebecea Holsberry, or contin-
Orlando and Dora B. Johnson were not necessary parties to this suit. They purchased their land from U. F. Hols-berry, and had their deed recorded long before the land was liable to the judgment of appellant, and therefore have both legal and equitable rights prior to appellant’s; and he could not have the liens prior to his lifted from the remaining lands of U. F. Holsberry onto their lands for his benefit. On the contrary, they would have the right to have all existing liens and charges shifted from their land onto the remaining lands, for their relief and protection.
Appellant filed but one exception to the commissioner’s report, and this is to the allowance of the charge on the lands of U. F. Holsberry in favor of 'William and Rebecca Holsberry, respectively, for their life-maintenance, amounting to the sum of one thousand six hundred and sixty six dollars and twenty two cents, which exception was overruled by the court, and the amount decreed a lien on the land. The law is well settled that an implied equitable lien does not exist in favor of a vendor of real estate to secure the consideration therefor when such consideration is the mainten-anceand support of the grantors during life. McCandlish v. Keen, 13 Gratt. 615; Brawley v. Catron, 8 Leigh, 522; Arlin v. Brown, 44 N. H. 102; Hiscock v. Norton, 42 Mich. 320 (3 N. W. 868); McKillip v. McKillip, 8 Barb. 552; Chase v. Peck, 21 N. Y. 581; Meigs v. Dimock, 6 Conn. 458; Hobson v. Edwards, 57 Miss. 128; 1 Perry, Trusts, § 235; 28 Am. &. Eng. Enc. Law, 165. In the case of Peters v. Tunell, 43 Minn. 473 (45 N. W. 867) the reason given is “that the court can not accurately ascertain and define the amount of the charge to be imposed.” “What was required to be done was contingent and uncertain, depending upon future events, impossible to be calculated or ascertained, and this uncertainty as to what was to be done would continue indefinitely.” A person conveying real estate may create alien thereon, and charge the same with his support and maintenance by express words, showing his intention to charge the land. McClure v. Cook,
The decree complained of will be reversed in so far as it allows to William Holsberry and Rebecca Ilolsberry the two sums of eight hundred andthirty three dollars and eleven cents, respectively, aggregating the sum of one thousand six hundred and sixty six dollars and twenty two cents, and they will be dismissed from the suit, at the plaintiff’s costs; and in all other respects the decree will be affirmed, with costs to appellant, and case remanded for further proceedings.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.