Hunter v. Tolbard
Cases that cite this one
1 later published case cites this decision.
- C. A. House Co. v. Hazlett (W. Va. 1930)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
On the 18th of February, 1895, Tolbard and Hunter entered into an agreement in writing by which said Tolbard contracted to let Hunter have one-half interest in all the lumber outfit belonging to the Bartlett camp, four pairs of horses, and the camp outfit and wood tools, including everything; Hunter agreeing to pay Tolbard one -thousand dollars for the one-half interest, and to receive one-half of the profits of work done with said outfit. The one thous- and dollars mentioned was not to be taken out until the business was in shape to pay it, and Hunter was to have a salary of two dollars per day for running the job. On the first Monday in February, 1898, Hunter filed his bill in the circuit court of Tucker County against Tolbard, in which he stated, among other things, that he was a practical lumberman, and had the reputation of being a successful one in that portion of the State; that in February, 1895, he entered into a partnership with defendant, at his solicitation, for carrying out the terms of an agreement defendant had with the Blacliwater Lumber Company for furnishing logs, etc., and paid defendant one thousand dollars for orie-half interest in said contract, upon terms set forth in said agreement; that he entered upon his duties under said contract, which proved a very profitable one; and that on the 3d of April, 1897, having received but a small part of the profits arising from said work, he went to the defendant, and asked for a settlement, so that he could receive the profits then due him, but defendant refused to settle, and plaintiff being intoxicated, went home. Shortly after-wards, the defendant came to him with an agreement, already prepared, stating that .plaintiff must sign it, and then they would settle; and the plaintiff, being much intoxicated, unfit for business, very much in need of money, and
The question presented by the record and pleadings is whether the plaintiff by his bill has made such a case as entitles him to relief in a court of equity. As a matter of course, upon demurrer, all matters which are properly pleaded must be taken as true, and the demurrant simply says, conceding all of the allegations in the bill to be true, the plaintiff is not entitled to relief in a court of equity. Now, the plaintiff says that he had worked under his partnership contract with defendant until the 3d of April, 1897, when there was more than one thousand eight hundred dollars due him, and about that time he demanded a settlement, but defendant refused to settle; that on that day, when plaintiff was badly intoxicated, in g-reat need of money, and without knowing the true intent of the agreement brought to him by defendant, already prepared, he signed the same, which he charges was changed in important particulars after it was signed; that the manner in which the agreement was forced on him amounted to duress; that it was in direct violation of the good faith which should prevail between partners, and was obtained through
As, to the allegation in the bill that the plaintiff was intoxicated at the time he signed the agreement of April 3,1897, and from that cause was incapacitated from making a contract, we find the law thus stated in 3 Minor, Inst. pt. 1: “Where a fraudulent advantage is taken of, drunkenness: This is so direct and palpable a fraud as always to render the transaction voidable in all the courts, whether of law or equity,” — citing numerous authorities, and among them Reynalds v. Waller's Heir, 1 Wash. (Va.) 164; Harvey v. Pecks, 1 Munf. 518. The author also says: “Where the drunkenness is so total as to have deprived the party of his reason and of an agreeing mind: In this case, without any reference to any question of fraud, there being an absolute want of understanding, without which there-can be no contract, the transaction, whatever it may be, is not, as in other cases, voidable, only, but wholly void.” On this point, see, also, 2 Pom. Eq. Jur. § 949; Bish. Cont. § 980; 11 Am. & Eng. Enc. Law, 773.
The facts alleged in the bill must be regarded as true on demurrer, and, in my opinion, are sufficent, if proven, to
Reversed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.