Dudley v. Barrett
Cases that cite this one
20 later published cases cite this decision.
- WV Department of Health & Human Resources Employees Federal Credit Union v. Tennant (W. Va. 2004)
- Delong v. Kermit Lumber & Pressure Treating Co. (W. Va. 1985)
- Employers' Liability Assurance Corp. v. Hartford Accident & Indemnity Co. (W. Va. 1967)
- Pozzie v. Prather (W. Va. 1967)
- Grottendick v. Webber (W. Va. 1950)
- State v. Taylor (W. Va. 1947)
- Bank of Gassaway v. James (W. Va. 1928)
- Spindler v. Hamilton (W. Va. 1912)
- Woods v. King (W. Va. 1906)
- State v. Banks (W. Va. 1906)
- Coal Run Coal Co. v. Cecil (W. Va. 1923)
- Shipley v. Virginian Ry. Co. (W. Va. 1920)
- McCray v. Craig & Sons (W. Va. 1912)
- Carr & Keys v. Coal Co. (W. Va. 1908)
- DeBoard v. Camden Interstate Railway Co. (W. Va. 1907)
- Chadister v. Baltimore & Ohio Railroad (W. Va. 1907)
- Schwarzchild & Sulzberger Co. v. Chesapeake & Ohio Railway Co. (W. Va. 1906)
- State ex rel. Billingsley v. Stutler (W. Va. 1906)
- Grant v. Wyatt (W. Va. 1906)
- Coal & Coke Railway Co. v. Joyce (W. Va. 1905)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
In this action of assumpsit by J. W. Dudley against J. R. Barrett and A. J. Hannaman, in the circuit court of Wood county, there was a trial by jury and a verdict for plaintiff for $664.52, a motion by defendants to set aside the verdict, which motion was overruled and defendants excepted, and judgment was entered for plaintiff, to which a writ of error was allowed defendants, by a judge of this Court.
Again, if the certificate of evidence made by John T. Harris could be considered as part of the record, it still does not appear that such certificate of evidence contains all the evidence adduced upon the trial, and, therefore, we must presume that there was evidence which fully sustained the verdict. State v. Ice, 34 W. Va. 244; Bank v. Bank, 3 W. Va. 386; Edgell v. Conway, 24 W. Va. 747; Hunter v. Stewart, 23 W. Va. 549; Smith v. Walker, 1 Call (Va.) 24; Willard v. Overseers, 9 Grat. (Va.) 139.
The evidence adduced on the trial of this action not being a part of the record, we cannot consider the assignments of error made, but must affirm the judgment. Tracy's Adm'x v. Carver Coal Co., supra; McKendree v. Shelton, supra; Cushwa v. Lamar, 45 W. Va. 326; Wustland v. Potterfield, 9 W. Va. 438; Laidley v. County Court, 44 W. Va. 566; Williamson v. Hays, 35 W. Va. 52; Richmond v. Henderson, 48 W. Va. 389.
Affvnned.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.