Mitchell v. Davis
Cases that cite this one
1 later published case cites this decision.
- Armco, Incorporated, a Corporation v. United Pocahontas Coal Company, a Corporation National Bulk Carriers, Incorporated, a Corporation (4th Cir. 1993)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
A. B. Mitchell and Joseph McNeeley recovered a judgment in assumpsit against H. A. Davis, W. H. Muth and L. S. Davis, partners doing business in the name of the Gém Lumber Company, for the sum of $641.60, and defendants were awarded this writ of error. The suit was brought to recover an alleged balance due on a logging contract. Defendants were operating a sawmill and had built a tram-road to some timber which they had purchased, and plaintiffs contracted to cut and haul the timber and place it on skids at the sawmill, at the price of $5.00 per thousand feet, scale measure, they to have the use of the tram-road. The case is similar in many respects to the one of Mitchell & Adkins against these same defendants, decided at the present term of this court. They both
The matters in controversy arise out of the following provisions in the contract: “Party of second part are to put 8000 feet on skids at mill per day and party of first part to saw 8000 feet per day, and should either party fail to do so, they shall forfeit seventy five cents per 1000 feet for each day to party damaged. Said forfeit not to apply, in case of providential interference or rather hinderanee beyond the control of either party.” * * * * * “It is agreed that party of first part are to retain 20% of amount of each month’s work for first three months as a guarantee that the longest haul will be done and when it is done then said 20% becomes due and payable, otherwise it- will be retained by parties of first part to help pay additional cost of hiring said longest haul and when done, should any remain it will be due and payable to party of second part.”
Defendants claim damages on two grounds: (1) Liquidated damages for plaintiffs’ failure to deliver on the skids at the sawmill 8000 feet of logs per day, and (2) unliquidated damages for their abandoning the- contract before the longest haul was completed. It is admitted that not more than 495,657 feet of logs were delivered up to December 1, 1910, the time covered by this suit. This was 963,315 feet short of a daily average of 8000 feet, which, at seventy five cents per thousand, amounts to $722.48. It is also admitted that the forfeiture of seventy-five cents per thousand was intended as liquidated damages, and not as a penalty. Defendants sought to set-off or recoup this sum against plaintiffs’ demand, and the jury found against them. There is evidence tending to prove that the failure to deliver 8000 feet daily was owing, in part at least, to the default of defendants; and, in view of
The jury also rejected defendants’ set-off, or recoupment of $244.61, which they claimed as damages for plaintiffs’ failure to complete the job. This item was claimed under the second clause above quoted from the contract, authorizing the retention of 20% to secure the long haul. The job was abandoned before all the timber was hauled, and defendants claim that it cost them $244.61 more to have the logging com
There is no dispute as to the quantity of timber hauled by plaintiffs, or as to the correctness of the amount for which they sue. The only controverted questions relate to defendants’ right of recoupment or sets-off, and their right thereto resting on controverted facts, the existence of which depend solely upon conflicting oral testimony, the court is not authorized to disturb the verdict.
The judgment is affirmed.
Affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.