Prager v. City of Wheeling
Cases that cite this one
3 later published cases cite this decision.
- Modular Building Consultants of West Virginia, Inc. v. Poerio, Inc. (W. Va. 2015)
- Mitchell Brozik and MB Security v. Betty Parmer, etc. (W. Va. 2017)
- Ashley D. Gunno v. Kevin C. McNair (W. Va. 2016)
This list shows which later cases cite this one. It does not say how they treated it, and no review of that has been done. Not a substitute for Shepard’s or KeyCite — verify before relying.
Opinion of the Court
The city of Wheeling prosecutes this writ of error from a final judgment of the circuit court entered on the 18th day of February, 1922.
The plaintiff, nineteen 'years of age and inexperienced in the performance of the duties of his employment, was employed by the city as an oiler at its water works pumping station. He was required to wipe, oil and grease three eccentrics, a part of the pump, and while so engaged his head was caught between one of the eccentrics and the edge of a platform near it, causing him serious injury. The city had not elected to comply with ¡the requirements of the workmen’s compensation law. The declaration contained three counts, the first of which charged the city with having failed to provide safe and proper machinery; the second charged the city with not having provided a reasonably safe place for the plaintiff to work; and the third was based upon the alleged failure of the city to properly and sufficiently instruct the plaintiff at the time of the employment of the dangers and risks of the employment. Special interrogatories were propounded to the jury on the trial, and it may be conceded that the answers to these interrogatories, would relieve the city from liability under the first two counts.
Tbe duty which plaintiff was required to discharge, was to wipe tbe grease off of certain eccentrics vdiich were a part of tbe machinery used in tbe operation of tbe pumps at tbe pumping station. He was furnished to tbe city as an experienced and capable oiler and wiper by a labor union which had contracted with tbe city to furnish it competent and experienced men. He was inexperienced and of immature age. It is difficult to determine from tbe record tbe exact relative locations of the eccentrics, and the platform on which tbe plaintiff stood at tbe time of tbe injury, and tbe one against which bis bead was crushed by movement of tbe eccentric. It appears that a photograph was in evidence at tbe trial; and tbe jury was taken to the pumping-station and observed tbe machinery and .eccentrics in motion and were given a demonstration of tbe manner in which the wiping was done. However, it appears tbat these eccentrics were three in number and were located on one deck or plane, near to each other, and on the side of each of which was a small metal platform. The eccentrics were located at unequal distances from the platforms, the one in the center at which the accident occurred being 5% inches from the platform on which the plaintiff stood while performing his duty. At the time of the injury, while the plaintiff was
The contentions of the parties are based on whether the evidence was sufficient for the jury to determine if this duty of the city to the defendant was, sufficiently discharged. When the plaintiff began his work he was instructed by the witness Cunningham, who appears to be a competent and experienced man, the method of oiling and cleaning the different parts of the pumps and especially how to wipe the eccentrics, and his attention directed, in a general sort of way, to the dangers of the work. He told the plaintiff to be careful in wiping the. eccentrics, and if his oil can
There is a substantial conflict in the evidence as to whether the plaintiff was sufficiently and properly warned of the particular danger which caused the injury, a conflict to be determined by the jury. It was the positive duty of the defendant to give the plaintiff such instructions and warning of the dangers, and the failure to do it constituted negligence for which it was. liable. This issue was presented to the jury by instruction No. 6 for the plaintiff, which in substance told them that if they believed that the employment was dangerous; that the defendant knew the plaintiff to be inexperiencedand did not give him sufficient instructions as to the danger incident to the performance of his duties, then by reason of such failure of the defendant to properly instruct and warn, they should find for the plaintiff. Defendant’s instruction No: E told the jury that if they should find that the plaintiff had been carefully and properly instructed in his work by the defendant and had been warned or knew of the dangers thereof he could not 'recover under the third count of the declaration.
Can it be said that the danger of being caught between the eccentric and the edge of the platform where the plaintiff was injured was so palpable and apparent to the plaintiff that instructions and warnings were not necessary and that he should have perceived the danger and avoided it? The plaintiff testified that he had not thought of this danger and had not perceived it. ITe expressed it by saying, “I never thought that far.” It must be remembered that the jury was taken to where the accident occurred, and observed the machinery in motion and saw where the plaintiff stood in the performance of his duty, and was given an ocular demonstration of the method in which the grease was wiped from the eccentric, and evidently with this evidence were convinced that the danger was. not so plain and apparent that instructions and warnings were unnecessary.
We think the evidence is sufficient to sustain the verdict, and the judgment is affirmed.
Affirmed.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.