SER J.C., a Minor v. Hon. James P. Mazzone, Lead Presiding Judge
Opinion
No. 14-0207 - State of West Virginia ex rel. J.C., a minor, by and through his mother and next friend, Michelle Cook, et al. v. The Honorable James P. Mazzone, Lead Presiding Judge, Zoloft Litigation, Mass Litigation Panel; Pfizer, Inc.; Roerig, a division of Pfizer, Inc.; and Greenstone, LLC, f/k/a Greenstone, LTD
FILED May 27, 2014 released at 3:00 p.m. RORY L. PERRY II, CLERK SUPREME COURT OF APPEALS
OF WEST VIRGINIA LOUGHRY, Justice, concurring:
I agree with the majority’s holdings regarding Rule 3(a) and Rule 20 of the West Virginia Rules of Civil Procedure, but write separately to emphasize that the majority’s opinion should not be read as diminishing the avenues available to litigants for challenging whether parties were permissibly joined into one action under Rule 20. The Panel’s stated intent in proposing what became the 2008 amendment to Rule 3(a) clearly exceeded what was contemplated by this Court in Cable,1 as the majority has fully explained. While the Panel urges us to interpret Rule 3(a) as a substantive rule creating multiple civil actions2 and warns that any other interpretation could result in West Virginia from becoming a “dumping ground for foreign lawsuits,” the fact remains that there are established tools to prevent such an event from occurring. Challenges, such as a motion to dismiss based on forum non conveniens under West Virginia Code § 56-1-1a (2012),3 or a motion to dismiss fraudulently or improperly joined parties,4 are available to litigants. In short, misjoined claims and parties may still be addressed through appropriate procedural and substantive challenges.5
I also agree with the majority that Rule 3(a) cannot be interpreted in a manner that essentially nullifies Rule 20, which provides that “[a]ll persons may join in one action as plaintiffs . . . .” While I appreciate the Panel’s argument regarding the manner in which Rule 3(a) dovetails with Trial Court Rule 26.04(a)(2) as it pertains to “civil actions,” the Panel failed to address permissive joinder under Rule 20 in its brief filed in this Court, even though the interplay between Rule 20 and Rule 3(a) was the focus of the other parties’ arguments in this matter. In fact, the Panel’s lack of discussion in this regard is arguably an implicit recognition of the conflict between Rule 20 and the Panel’s interpretation of Rule 3(a). Additional rule amendments and revisions may well be necessary to address the Panel’s litigation management concerns, but it must be done in a manner that does not affront permissive joinder.
Lastly, I do not understand why the majority felt compelled to recommend the Federal Judicial Center’s Manual for Complex Litigation, Fourth (2004), to the Panel as a “good source of suggestions on how to efficiently handle complex mass litigation issues[.]” The majority quotes the federal manual’s definitions of “liaison counsel” and “lead counsel,” as if these definitions and ideas are a novel concept, when our own Trial Court Rule 26.05 already defines these very terms. And, given the obvious similarities between the definitions of these terms in the federal manual versus our Trial Court Rules, our definitions may well have been based on the definitions in the federal manual. Indeed, I am confident that the Panel has utilized this federal manual on many occasions for guidance and “suggestions” in its development of mechanisms and plans for organization and procedure of mass litigation. Consequently, I find the majority’s recommendation of this federal manual to the Panel to be unnecessary.
For the reasons set forth above, I respectfully concur in the majority’s holdings, as reflected in its opinion.
Case-law data current through September 30, 2026. Source: CourtListener bulk data.